New Century and Integrity Plus Blog

The Ins-and-Outs of ILI Run Comparison

Posted by Phil Tisovec on Sep 20, 2017 12:59:18 PM

Find me on:

An In-Line Inspection (ILI) is really just a snapshot of the current condition of your pipeline on a specific date. Depending on the technology used and when the pipeline is inspected, different “views” of the pipe’s condition are created. Which means no single ILI will give you the true condition of your pipeline

This is where run comparisons come into play. Run comparisons help QC new data building confidence in the results, increases the value of each run, and provides data for deeper and more accurate analytics using the comparison results. 

There are a handful of options when it comes to doing an ILI run comparison; completing it in-house, outsourcing to an ILI vendor, outsourcing to a service provider, or maybe your organization just doesn’t do it. Trying to decide what is best for your organization? We’ve got your benefits and drawbacks of each.

ILI Vendor Comparison

Benefits

  • Part of a “package deal” with an ILI run
  • Experts in the technology
  • Anomalies compared prior to application of interaction rules
  • Raw data readily available for review

Drawbacks

  • Locked into same vendor, limiting choice and higher pricing
  • Potential bias
  • Can slow down report delivery

In-House Comparison

Benefits

  • Vendor and technology independent
  • Preserve matches for future comparison
  • Can compare beyond anomalies (taps, tees, etc.)
  • Control over analysis, timing and priority

Drawbacks

  • Time-consuming, takes up resources
  • Staff may be in-experienced or under-qualified
  • Potential bias in results

Service Provider Comparison

Benefits

  • Same as In-House (above)
  • No bias in results

Drawbacks

  • Difficulty sharing raw data for review due to size

Knowing the true condition of your pipeline, including any potential integrity threats, is an important decision-making factor and can end up saving you lots of money down the road. Using the results of effective ILI run comparisons help organizations resolve threats without digging, allow conditions to be monitored, and provide more detailed and accurate Growth, Re-inspection and other FFP analysis.

To learn more about ILI run comparison approaches and common pitfalls, view our free webinar A Look at Vendor-Agnostic ILI Run Comparison or contact the Integrity Plus ILI team to see how they can assist with your run comparisons. 

Topics: Integrity Management, ILI, ILI Run Comparison

Subscribe to Email Updates

Recent Posts

Posts by Topic

see all

Follow Us